Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

For more than a century, Naegelin's Bakery has produced and perfected the best pastries, desserts and cakes in Texas.  As the oldest bakery in the state and a reputation with making delectable treats, the staff continues to bring loyal patrons to the door every day with a vast array of famous baked goodies.

Beyond their extensive options, Naegelin’s is also famous for their delicious wedding cakes.  Good taste shouldn’t have to be expensive, and at Naegelin’s you can get excellence at affordable price. Don't let their New Braunfels location deter you from calling as they also serve the San Antonio area by delivery.

We're looking forward to celebrating with you! Please contact us for a quote today!

Phone:  (830) 625-5722



Regular Cake: Vanilla, Chocolate
Specialty Cakes: Red Velvet, Carrot, German Chocolate, Italian Cream, Lemon, Confetti, Strawberry, Chocolate chunk, Banana, and Almond.

Extra cost Specialty Flavors: Amaretto

Regular Icing: Vanilla Buttercream, Chocolate Buttercream

Specialty Icing: German Chocolate, Cream Cheese, Rolled Fondant. 

Specialty Filling: Raspberry Fruit or Mousse, Strawberry Fruit or Mousse, Cherry, Lemon, Lime, Fudge, Custard, Pineapple fruit or mousse, Apple, Chocolate Mousse, Vanilla Mousse, Cream Cheese, banana, and blueberry. 

*Cream cheese, Buttercream and fondant icings ONLY on wedding cakes and custom cake designs.*


How Soon Should I Order a Cake?

We recommend that wedding cakes be booked at least 3 months in advance and party cakes at least 2 weeks in advance. Because we are limited to the number of cakes we can accommodate, it is on a first scheduled basis. We will try to accommodate last minute requests - please call for fastest response!

How Much Do Your Wedding Cakes Cost?

***This is a baseline price list only.***  

Custom cakes can be very simple and elegant or very involved and time consuming. Base Prices Include Buttercream filling and frosting, with simple decor. Each cake is made to order and priced accordingly.  Please e-mail or call for exact quote.

Base Wedding Cake/Custom Cake Pricing:

Basic Buttercream start at $4.50 per servings.
Carved 3D - priced to each custom order.
All Fondant start at $6.50 per serving.
Gum Paste and Fondant Figures vary according to design.
Cream Cheese $4.75 per serving

What Method of Payment Do You Accept?

Cash, Check, & Credit Card. 

Do you work with any specific partners? 

We do! Check them out here: Partner Page

Custom Order Policy

Placing an Advance Order

A full deposit is required for all custom cake orders.
Payment of the deposit is required to obtain a reservation on the calendar.
Availability to accept an order will be determined as of the day and time that the deposit is paid.
A specific date may not be reserved prior to finalizing the details for the order.
Full payment must be completed 7 days prior to the due date. Failure to finalize your order and complete the deposit process on time may result in forfeiture of your reservation on the calendar. 

Changing an Order

Order changes which do not change the price or which increase the price, will be considered up to 8 days prior to the reservation date, provided that any increase in the required deposit amount is paid at the time of the change.
Rush changes for design ONLY will be considered if they are requested at least 3 days prior to the event.
Changes to an order which result in a reduction in the price must be made 7 days prior to the reservation date. Any refund due to the Client will be paid by Naegelin’s on the reservation date or at the time of change.
Naegelin’s ability to accommodate Client change requests is dependent upon the number and complexity of all reservations booked on a particular date. 

Canceling an Order

Cancellation requests must be made within 7 days or more before the reservation date.

This policy does not apply to those special event orders which are booked with our separate Wedding Cake Contract Form. For those orders, the terms of the contract will apply.


DELIVERY: Naegelin's has FREE delivery inside  New Braunfels city limits, as long as it is not on a Sunday or after hours(an additional fee will be applied in those circumstances). To deliver anywhere outside New Braunfels city limits, there is a delivery fee of $1.50 per mile , round trip.  We do not ship cakes or deliver more than 1 hour away.  We are not responsible for damage resulting from tables that are not level, weak, too small, or placed in a warm area. Please keep in mind that there can be wind, rain, temperature, pets, bugs, or other situations, especially for outdoor deliveries that can harm or cause damage to your cake. We are not responsible for any damage to your cake(s) for any reason after setup is complete.

UNAVOIDABLE OCCURRENCE: In the case of an unavoidable occurrence, such as a car accident, poor road conditions, traffic during delivery etc. Naegelin's Bakery CANNOT be held liable for more than the price of the cake ordered.

PICKING UP YOUR CAKE:  Picking up your cake is a great way to save money, but is not recommended for cakes bigger than our smallest 3 tier cake.  Deliveries must be made for cakes bigger then our smallest 3 tier. If you choose to pick up your cake you should make sure that you have a clean, flat, “non-slip” surface in an air conditioned area to transport the cake while driving.  If you are in a car, the floor is generally safer than the seat.   Most of our cakes are either too large or irregularly shaped to fit in a cake box so you need to take special care to protect them. Once you leave with the cake it is no longer the responsibility of Naegelin's Bakery.


CAKE PICTURES:  We photograph our cakes and we reserve the right to use any photographs for display or promotional uses without compensation to you, or without your permission.

 FOOD ALLERIES:  Our products may contain or come into contact with milk, wheat, nuts, and other allergens. You agree to notify your guests of this risk and hold us harmless for allergic reactions.  

 NON-EDIBLE ITEMS:  Naegelin's Bakery will not be responsible for any non-edible items (silk flowers, pearls, ribbons, etc.) placed on your cake. All non-edible items are to be provided by you; we will gladly decorate and place these items on your cake as you wish, however it is your responsibility to remove them before the cake is consumed.